Seriously, person at small press? Seriously?! You who are an Associate Publisher--Really?!
You have me call you to get my rejection because you're too chaotically busy to write it down and send it? How about just, "Thanks. It wasn't what we were looking for." But instead you tell me you have notes to pass along from an editor who has departed and "another staffer."
So I call in for my rejection, but you start rambling about Augusten Burroughs and how his memoirs work, which is confusing because you didn't read my memoir. I am writing my memoir in fact. So I just keep listening to see where this is going, and you tell me, you probably should have someone's notes in front of you because you didn't really read much of my manuscript, but you are just insanely busy, so you're working from your memory about what was wrong with the manuscript you keep referring to as my memoir.
Finally, I can't take it anymore, so I interrupt: "Um," says I. "You asked to read my collection of published essays based on an essay that appeared in the New York Times, not my memoir. You didn't ask for my memoir. But what you read was a collection of published essays."
And what do you say? You say: "Oh."
Then there is an awkward silence in which I ought to have let you merely tread water, but I was too embarrassed and somehow co-dependent. Embarrassed for me and you and publishing in general.
So, I launch into some long rambling something (what the hell was I saying?) that ends with, "Who would really publish a book of published essays by someone who isn't famous anyway?" and "But really you are publishing some very nice works, and thanks for the consideration." (As my friend says, Aw, no, you made her feel better?)
I did. And I shouldn't have. But what, really, should I have said?
I'm thinking of two not very nice words, but you guys can probably come up with something more creative.
What would you have said?
Search This Blog
Wednesday, July 11, 2012
Tuesday, July 10, 2012
Call Me For Your Verbal Rejection
I dread it of course, but what can I do? Tell her to buck up and write my rejection like everyone else does? No. I will call her and be gracious and thank her for her time. After all, it's not every day that you get a phone rejection from a still-independent small press.
Monday, July 9, 2012
No Nelligan for you
Above is the photo banner for the 2012 Nelligan Prize for Short Fiction. Who is she? Who is on the phone? Why does she look so blank? Weird, no? Anyway, below is the standard rejection for the prize sent in by an LROD reader:
Thank you for entering the 2012 Nelligan Prize for Short Fiction. As always, the selection of a winner was a difficult process as there were so many excellent stories, but we are pleased to announce that final judge Jane Hamilton has selected Matthew Shaer's "Ghosts" as this year’s winner. This story will appear in the fall/winter 2012 issue of Colorado Review, to be published in late November.
Again, thank you for entering. I hope you will consider us again for next year’s competition.
With kindest regards,
Stephanie G'Schwind
Editor, Colorado Review
Friday, July 6, 2012
Control Your Wrath, O Rejected One
The weather turned nasty out there, hurricane like last week. Maybe they shouldn't have rejected you so glibly:
Thank you for sending us your manuscript to the Antioch Review. The return of your work does not necessarily imply criticism of its merit, but may simply mean that it does not meet our present editorial needs. We regret that circumstances do not allow individual comment. The Editors
Sunday, July 1, 2012
Geniuses versus Mediocrities: Who Wins?
In this single historical rejection, we have the problem of publishing summed up very nicely:
Catch – 22 by Joseph Heller: "I haven’t really the foggiest idea about what the man is trying to say… Apparently the author intends it to be funny – possibly even satire – but it is really not funny on any intellectual level … From your long publishing experience you will know that it is less disastrous to turn down a work of genius than to turn down talented mediocrities."(The clue phone rings for you.)
Thursday, June 28, 2012
This Just In From Your Friend and Mine
Dear Writers, Rejected:
I had promised a number of years ago that if I ever placed a short story collection, your readers would be the first to know. I am delighted to report that I am able to fulfill that pledge. My collection, Scouting for the Reaper, has won this year's Hudson Prize and will be published by Black Lawrence Press. Your readers will be amused to know that my total rejection count for creative work now includes slightly more 25,000 rejection letters. I have published slightly more than 200 stories. Mathematics is not my strong suit, so I'll leave it to you to calculate my placement percentage. I thank you for all of your kind words and support over the years.
Jacob M. Appel
I had promised a number of years ago that if I ever placed a short story collection, your readers would be the first to know. I am delighted to report that I am able to fulfill that pledge. My collection, Scouting for the Reaper, has won this year's Hudson Prize and will be published by Black Lawrence Press. Your readers will be amused to know that my total rejection count for creative work now includes slightly more 25,000 rejection letters. I have published slightly more than 200 stories. Mathematics is not my strong suit, so I'll leave it to you to calculate my placement percentage. I thank you for all of your kind words and support over the years.
Jacob M. Appel
Tuesday, June 26, 2012
Folded in Half and Shoved in SASE
A little flippant? Or simply to-the-point? It's hard to say. I can't tell if it's cute or irritating. Both, I guess. Certainly, the sign off is a bit much, but what do I know. People have their own style. "Pax!" What's the Latin word for "Give me a break, Dude."
Friday, June 22, 2012
Words to Live By
"...don’t get bitter about rejections, ever. Transform whatever bad feelings you might have into useful feelings; you should never feel ashamed about a rejection."--Sheila Heti (author of How Should A Person Be?)A-novel-a-year novelist Sheila Heti offers the above advice here, which is sound. She has the kind of career I always wanted to have, but alas, I'm more the book-every-decade-or-longer type of writer. Oh well, hope in the end it's worth all the time it takes. She also has a super cute hair do. Just saying.
Tuesday, June 19, 2012
Flat Out Familiar
I went to Amazon today to check on a book I ordered and this was the message from Amazon's CEO was waiting for me on my home page:
Dear Customers,
"Did I cry over some of these rejections? Absolutely. Did I feel inadequate, untalented, hurt? Yes. Did I doubt my ability to craft a story that readers could fall in love with? You bet."
That's Jessica Park, who hit road block after road block trying to get her book Flat-Out Love in front of readers. You can read her incredible blog post on IndieReader (also picked up by HuffPo) detailing her perseverance and how she finally succeeded by doing it herself with Kindle Direct Publishing. It's heartwarming and tells a powerful story about what KDP makes possible.Hmm....congratulations to her, right?
Monday, June 18, 2012
Puritanical Rejection
As few words as possible, pilgrim; it's cold in these parts:
Dear Writer: Though your work has been declined by our editors, we thank you for allowing us to consider it. Sincerely, The Editors of The Massachusetts Review
Monday, June 11, 2012
Why Is Waiting Always the Answer?
My spouse and the friend who edited my book of short stories years ago convinced me not to let my agent read the novel yet. The argument: "You are so close to nailing this thing, why waste a non-perfect read on him." I am eager to get this ball rolling (after 15 years of false rolls), but I took the manuscript back and asked Secret Agent Man to hold up on reading. I figure, these are my peeps, closest to my work, but with more perspective than I have, so I'm going with their advice. It's always a hard question: when to give a manuscript out to read and when to hold it back? I am impatient and always send stuff out too early. Not this time, though. I'm not going to let myself get in the way. In good news, though, three readers (including spouse and friend/editor) have started reading the new first-person version and they think it's just what the novel needed. Phew! That's my news for today. What's happening with you mice? Any advice about timing and when to send something out?
Friday, June 8, 2012
Social Media, Social Media, Social Media
But will it save you from literary rejection? This article at Business2Community has some words on the matter and a very tenuous (IMHO) association. But check it out anyway and then forget it, but have a nice weekend.
Wednesday, June 6, 2012
Happy Anniversary LROD
Two days ago was my 1,500th post and tomorrow is the 5-year anniversary of this blog. Perhaps it's a good time to take a moment and review.
- For those of you who don't know, I started this blog by posting a backlog of my very own rejections and went for a good long time until I ran out.
- Then I posted some rejections that came along in real-time.
- Then you all started sending me your rejections which has been interesting.
- Then we started a bunch of conversations about the state of publishing which has declined greatly these past 5 years.
- During this time I have published a bunch of things, but not another book, which is disappointing. I have also revised my novel many times and had a few agents interested who ultimately walked away.
- My family has gone crazy over my public writing about being disinherited and about them in essence.
- A bunch of publishers got excited about the disinheritance book proposal, but ultimately walked away.
- A small press is potentially interested in a book of my published essays, but they have not gotten back to me with an answer, and plus my family will FREAK out if it gets published, so there's that.
- I finally put my family way on the outside of my life. In fact, they can go for a flying fuck if they would like to; I'm done.
- Just last month I took my "third-person omniscient" point of view and turned it into first-person weird" point of view which has revolutionized the novel, now so many years in the making it's embarrassing to give it a number in public. (Related to the above bullet? probably)
- Will the novel get published now? I don't know. Secret Agent Man is giving it a read (new to him), as are a few other trusted readers. So cross your fingers for me, peeps.
Oh, and happy anniversary to you too. You mice make this blog worth writing and reading.
Tuesday, June 5, 2012
Thank You Very Much!
Dear Writer: I am very sorry to inform you that our judge did not select your story for this year’s fiction award at Washington Square. I do, however, want to thank you very much for submitting, and hope you will think of us in the future. Best, Lizzie Harris Washington Square Awards Editor
Monday, June 4, 2012
Read the Winner, Loser; Subscription is Free
Thank you for submitting "Title of your Work" to The Willow Springs Fiction Prize. Unfortunately, your story was not selected as this year's winner. We do hope you enjoy the chosen story, which will be featured in Willow Springs issue 70. As a contest entrant, your subscription to the magazine will begin with this issue. We wish you the best of luck in placing your story elsewhere. Sincerely, The Editors, Willow Springs
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













